My thoughts on every player who played for the 2017 Royals.
The Hitters:
Jorge Bonifacio – A rookie who was probably not expected to
be on the team during spring training, Bonifacio had a pretty decent year. He
showed good power, hitting 17 homers, but struck out a lot, and isn’t a good
defensive player. He rarely played after the Royals acquired Melky Cabrera, and
in retrospect, it might have been better just to leave him in right field.
Billy Burns – Not much to say about Billy. He was up briefly
and only got 6 at bats. I suspect if we need a spot on the 40 man roster, he
will be the first to go.
Drew Butera – Was signed to a 2 year contract to be Salvy’s
backup, a job that is pretty similar to being the Maytag repairman. Played when
Salvy had the side issue, but was very poor defensively. 7 passed balls? Will
likely serve in the same role in 2018 so he needs to improve the defense.
Melky Cabrera – Was acquired midseason when we were still in
the playoff hunt. Played well, but I’m not sure he was that much of an upgrade
over Bonifacio. I don’t expect him back in 2018.
Lorenzo Cain – Sometimes I don’t think I appreciate what a
terrific player Lorenzo Cain is. Gold Glove caliber defense, hit .300, 26
steals, 15 homers, extremely likeable guy. He always seems to walk like he just
pulled a hamstring. I don’t know who will play centerfield in 2018, but if Cain
isn’t back I will miss him. By the way, the trade of Greinke for Cain and
Escobar has to be one of the best trades in Royals history.
Christian Colon – Keeping Colon may have been the main
reason Whit Merrifield started the season in the minor leagues. I always liked
Colon, but he doesn’t really have the ability to be a starter. Nevertheless, he
was a key part of some of the biggest moments of the 2014-2015 seasons. For
that, I will always remember him fondly.
Cheslor Cuthbert – At the moment, Cuthbert looks like the
2018 starting third baseman. That is a concern. Decent enough as a backup, he
doesn’t hit or field well enough to be a starter. Injuries never really allowed
him to get going in 2017.
Alcides Escobar – I have to admit I love Esky. Plays every
day (literally), always plays hard, makes terrific plays at shortstop, good
base runner. He was one of our hottest hitters the last 2 months of the season.
I wish he had hit like that all year. He doesn’t hit homers, but hits a lot of
doubles and triples. What concerns me is: What happened to his base stealing
ability? 4 stolen bases, caught 7 times. In his previous 5 seasons with the
Royals, he was never caught more than 6 times, and he stole 35, 22, 31, 17, and
17 times. If he is not back in 2018, it
is likely the Royals have Raul Mondesi to take his place.
Cam Gallagher – Made a Royals fan very happy with a $25,000
Sonic Slam for his first major league home run. I really wish he had played
more in September rather than Butera. He looked like a pretty decent hitter,
and I would have liked to see what he could do.
Alex Gordon – What in the world has happened to Alex Gordon?
For most of the year, he looked completely lost at the plate. It seemed like
every time he got a pitch right down the middle, he would foul it off. Toward
the latter part of the year, he started to hit like the old Alex Gordon, but we
need him to be productive or we will have big problems going forward. He still
plays stellar defense.
Terrance Gore – Terrance Gore has one job. Pinch run and
steal a base. This year, he only stole 2 bases and was caught twice. Still
looking for his first major league hit. Gore really has no value except either
in September or maybe the playoffs. Otherwise, he is a waste of a roster spot,
and if we need a spot on the 40 man roster, I think Gore would be expendable.
Eric Hosmer – Eric is the soul of the Kansas City Royals.
Clearly the team leader, I feel the Royals have to resign him. He had a
terrific year offensively, hitting well over .300 with good power. He saves so
many errors with his ability to scoop low throws. The Royals seem to have a good
relationship with his agent Scott Boras so I hope they can work something out.
Whit Merrifield – I love to watch Whit play. He seems to
know what it takes to win baseball games. He started the season in the minors,
because the Royals wanted to hang onto Colon and Cuthbert, and Merrifield had
options. It seems almost ridiculous to think about now, but nobody could have
guessed he would have this kind of year. Last year in half a season, he hit 2
homers and stole 8 bases. How could anyone imagine this year he would hit 19
and lead the league in steals? He is still older than Eric Hosmer, so I wouldn’t
expect his numbers to improve a lot going forward, but right now he is a
fixture at second base.
Raul Mondesi – Our starting second baseman at the beginning
of the year, he frankly couldn’t hit. He did well at Omaha, where he probably
should have been in the first place. I think we have rushed Mondesi at almost
every level. Hence, his minor league numbers aren’t as good as they should be.
He clearly has talent, and I think he will be a really good player as long as
the Royals let him develop at his own pace.
Brandon Moss – It was easy to think Brandon Moss would hit
about 40 home runs. After all, every time he played against the Royals, he
looked like Babe Ruth. Unfortunately, he only hit 22. And barely hit above the
Mendoza line. A very pleasant guy, but there are way too many unproductive at
bats. He seems a bit like a left-handed Rob Deer. He will be back in 2018.
Mike Moustakas – At long last, someone finally broke Steve
Balboni’s long-standing Royals home run record. Moose showed the power we all
knew he had when we drafted him. The last couple of months of the season has
was hampered by a leg injury when he was hit by Bruce Rondon. I think that
affected him both at the plate and in the field. I really don’t expect Moose to
be back in 2018. I like Moose a lot, but as a hitter, when he isn’t hitting
home runs, he doesn’t provide much other offense. He doesn’t really hit a lot
of doubles or triples and his OBP is low. I think he will get a pretty good
contract this offseason, and the team that signs him may regret it.
Paulo Orlando – Paulo is a good guy to have as your 4th
outfielder. He gets exposed as a starter. Unfortunately, he had to start the
first month of the season, and didn’t do very well. Then he went to the minors
and broke his leg. Tough year for him, and I look for him to rebound in 2018.
But if he is in the Royals starting outfield on Opening Day, then something has
gone terribly wrong.
Salvador Perez – If Hosmer is the soul of the Royals, Salvy
is the heart. Salvy’s defensive numbers don’t look as good this year, mainly because
Royals pitchers were terrible at holding runners. Salvy set a new personal high
in homers and still seems to swing at everything. But I would still take Salvy
over every catcher in the American League. When he got hurt, the whole team
felt the impact. Our most irreplaceable player.
Jorge Soler – I know. We traded Wade Davis to get Soler. We
only had Davis for a year anyway, and we have Soler for 4. The jury is still
out on this trade. Soler had a rough year. He was injured the first month, then
got off to a slow start. He hit pretty well in Omaha, but when he came back up
to KC, he never got in a groove. He would play a game, go 0-for-4, then he
wouldn’t play for a week. Tough to get your timing as a hitter that way. I
expect him to lay claim to the starting role in 2018. This guy is a good
hitter; he just hasn’t gotten a chance to show it yet.
Ramon Torres – The quintessential utility infielder. Can
play several positions, but not much of a hitter. Will likely spend 2018 in the
minors.
The Pitchers:
Al Alburquerque – Al was a journeyman reliever who pitched a
few games for us. He wasn’t terrible, but he walked too many guys. Al, we
hardly knew ye.
Scott Alexander – Honestly, he was probably our most
valuable bullpen guy. He pitched in several roles and became a guy to go to in
pressure situations. He absolutely rescued us several times when thrown into a
critical situation. He will be a key part of the 2018 team.
Miguel Almonte – He only pitched 2 innings due to injuries.
Was at one time considered our best pitching prospect. I’d be surprised if we
ever see him again.
Ryan Buchter – He came over in the midseason trade with San
Diego and pitched pretty well. I think he will be used quite a bit out of the
2018 bullpen.
Trevor Cahill – Another guy who came in the trade with San
Diego. I think he was injured when he got here because he pitched pretty well
early in the year with the Padres. With us he was dreadful. We will not see him
in a Royals uniform again.
Danny Duffy – Our ace had a bad year. He pitched well enough
although not as good as we had hoped. Then he got injured. Then he got
arrested. Definitely a year to put behind him. I think he will be back and
ready to pitch on Opening Day 2018.
Luke Farrell – We called him up to pitch one game as the 26th
man during a doubleheader. He was horrific and has since been placed on waivers
and claimed by Cincinnati.
Neftali Feliz – The former Milwaukee closer came over and
pitched ok when we were short of pitchers. He looked nothing like his former
self though, and has since been released.
Brian Flynn – Boy, Flynn had a tough year. In the offseason
he fell through the roof of his barn, broke several vertebra, and was lucky to
be alive. Then he pitched one game, injured his groin, and was out for the rest
of the year. I hope he has a speedy recovery.
Onelki Garcia – In 2004, the Royals called up a pitcher
named Eduardo Villacis to start a game against the Yankees. I had never heard
of him. Manager Tony Pena had never heard of him. As might be expected, he was
terrible, and that was his only major league game. In 2017, the Royals called
up Onelki Garcia. I had never heard of him although he had pitched briefly with
the Dodgers in 2013. He pitched in relief August 27 in a game we lost 12-0 and
was terrible. Undaunted, we gave him a start September 2 against the Twins, and
he didn’t make it out of the first inning. That game reminded me of Joe Frazier
when he faced George Foreman. I could almost hear Howard Cosell’s voice saying,
“It’s target practice.” We lost that game 17-0. He has since been mercifully
released.
Sam Gaviglio – This was a good pickup on the part of the
Royals. People pooh-poohed the pickup because he was put on waivers by the
Mariners, but he made 2 starts and pitched well both times. I doubt he will be
in the 2018 rotation, but you need organizational depth.
Jason Hammel – Jason Hammel was signed after the tragic
death of Yordano Ventura. He pitched poorly initially, then pitched ok for a
while, then didn’t pitch well again. I think he probably pitched better than
his stats would indicate, but he still didn’t pitch well enough for a team
planning to compete. He will be back in 2018, but will I wouldn’t be surprised
to not see him make it through the year.
Kelvin Herrera – Herrera had a strange year. He started out as
the closer and did well. He’s not Wade Davis, but then who is? Then he started
battling some issues where he would lose feeling in his arm in mid-inning.
Scott Alexander came in to bail him out and Ned stopped using him in closing
situations. I’m not sure what to make of Herrera. I thought he would be a trade
candidate after the season, but since he lost his closer’s job, his value is
diminished. I still think there is a good chance he is traded in the offseason.
If not, I think he will be an 8th inning guy rather than a closer
next year.
Jakob Junis – The first 4 months of the year, Jakob Junis
was on the I-29 shuttle. A pitcher would get hurt and up came Junis. Then we
would get a new pitcher and Junis would head back to Omaha. Finally in August,
he came up and became part of our rotation. He pitched very well, dramatically
decreasing his walks, and seems to be slated for the 2018 rotation.
Nate Karns – We acquired Karns from Seattle for Jarrod
Dyson. I had always liked Karns and he pitched well, including a couple of
games where he had double digit strikeouts. Then he got the dreaded thoracic
outlet syndrome. I don’t really know what that is, but I know syndromes are
bad. He had surgery, and hopefully will be good as new next year.
Ian Kennedy – 5 wins. Kennedy showed flashes of pitching
well, but mostly he did not. I can’t help but think he was hurt most of the
year. His strikeout rate was the lowest of his career and I think he may have
had a neck injury from having to turn and watch the ball go over the fence. He
made 30 starts and gave up a home run in 24 of them. He can opt out of his
contract and become a free agent, but it would not be a wise career move
considering he will make $16 million in 2018. He will be back.
Andres Machado – He came up when we were desperate for arms,
and I guess he qualified as an arm. He got shelled in 2 brief appearances.
Seth Maness – I barely remember Maness pitching this year.
He was that nondescript. He actually appeared in 8 games and gave up 16 runs in
a little over 9 innings. No wonder I have erased him from my memory.
Brandon Maurer – This was another acquisition from San
Diego. It seemed like a good pickup at the time as he had been San Diego’s
closer on the rare occasions when San Diego had a game to close. He was in a word,
terrible. As one of 3 Royals eligible for arbitration (with Herrera and Karns),
I expect him to be non-tendered.
Kevin McCarthy – Kevin McCarthy pretty much stayed under the
radar. That is to say that he rarely pitched in high pressure situations, but
he pitched pretty well and gave our other bullpen guys a rest. If he is the
final guy on your staff, you are in pretty good shape.
Mike Minor – Minor is a former top prospect with Atlanta as
a starter. After several years of arm trouble, we put him into our bullpen and
he was probably our most effective reliever. He started out mainly pitching the
7th inning, then in August started pitching mainly the 8th
inning, and ended September pitching as the closer. He was good in every role.
The Royals have a $10 million mutual option with Minor for 2018 and I’m sure
they won’t exercise it. I think it is likely that Minor will resign with the
Royals but for a restructured contract something along the lines of 2 years for
$5 million a year.
Mike Morin – The Kansas City native was acquired late in the
season when we were (stop me if you’ve heard this before) desperate for
pitchers. He was strictly a mopup guy and I don’t expect to see him again.
Peter Moylan – Moylan appeared in more games in a season for
the Royals than anyone except Dan Quisenberry. He pitched really well and was
very effective against right-handed batters. He rarely faced more than a hitter
or two before he was removed for someone else. He had the unusual distinction
of pitching in 79 games, yet he wasn’t charged with a win, a loss, or a save. That
is a major league record. He is a free agent after the year, but I expect the
Royals to resign him. They don’t want to lose the espresso machine.
Eric Skoglund – What a great debut he had! 6 2/3 innings of
shutout ball in a game where the Royals beat the Tigers 1-0. Unfortunately, he
made 4 more starts and couldn’t get past the third inning in any of them. I
expect to see him at Omaha in 2018.
Joakim Soria – Joakim Soria seems to be everybody’s favorite
whipping boy. He could pitch well for 7 or 8 games, then give up an 8th
inning homer, and everyone wants him run out of town. He actually pitched
pretty well, and only gave up one homer all year, but if you ask the twitter
community they would tell you he gave up 50 homers. Jack will be back next
year.
Matt Strahm – Strahm looked really good in 2016, then
started off 2017 unable to find home plate. He went down to the minors and
pitched a little better when he came back before tearing up his knee. We shipped
him to the Padres at midseason and he was the key to the Padres making the
deal. He will probably get things back together and become a good pitcher down
the road.
Jason Vargas – Just as I predicted before the year, Jason
Vargas tied for the major league lead in wins. Just kidding. Who would have
guessed that Vargas, coming back from Tommy John surgery, would make the
All-Star team and have the kind of year he had? He had a little down turn after
the All-Star break, but picked it back up at the end of the year. It was really
a terrific season from Vargas. He will be a free agent and I don’t expect the
Royals to resign him.
Yordano Ventura – No discussion of the Royals pitching is
complete without mentioning Yordano Ventura. His death in January hovered like
a black cloud over the whole organization. First of all, he was one of our best
pitchers and at 25, had his best years ahead of him. Having him in our rotation
would have made a big difference in our starting pitching. Then his death
forced Dayton Moore to look for other starters. The two best free agent
starters at the time were Jason Hammel and Travis Wood, and Dayton signed both
of them. Neither of them were as good as Ventura would have been and in fact,
were considerably worse. Then we can’t really measure the effect Ventura’s
death had in the clubhouse. It might have caused the players to try too hard to
compensate for his loss, I don’t know. The Royals are a close-knit team, and
this might have taken some of the enjoyment out of playing the game.
Travis Wood – This was the other pitcher that Dayton Moore
signed upon the death of Ventura. He did not pitch well at any time and was
traded to San Diego in a deal where we picked up most of the salary.
Chris Young – In 2015, Chris Young was one of our most
important pitchers, both as a starter and a reliever. In 2017, he was done and
was released.
The Manager:
Ned Yost – There are actually a lot of Royals fans who don’t
like Ned Yost. That is incredible to me. Ned Yost took over the Royals in May
of 2010 after Trey Hillman got the axe. After Ned took over, the Royals
increased their win total every year for 6 STRAIGHT YEARS! They had won 65
games in 2009, then under Ned, they won 67 in 2010, 71 in 2011, 72 in 2012, 86
in 2013, 89 in 2014, and 95 in 2015. He took us to the World Series in 2014-15
and won a World Championship in 2015. Every year, the supposed experts pick us
to be lousy, and every year we beat those projections by plenty. Based on runs
scored and runs allowed, the Pythagorean projections for the last 4 years have
estimated we should have gone 84-78, 90-72, 77-85, and 72-90. Instead we have
gone 89-73, 95-67, 81-81, and 80-82. Jeez, he must be doing something right.
This year the Royals finished 13th out of 15 teams in runs scored,
and 10th in runs allowed, yet they were in the playoff hunt most of
the season, and finished 80-82. The Royals have a team unity like no team I
have seen before. You never hear players criticize the manager or each other.
Much of this has to be attributed to the manager. With any manager, you
sometimes disagree with his decisions, but I rarely find myself questioning
when Ned pulls a pitcher or something like that. I really expected Ned to
retire after this season, but he has said he plans to manage the Royals in
2018. Go Royals!